McLeodGaming Wiki
McLeodGaming Wiki
Tag: sourceedit
(I'd like to suggest the removal of the tier list page's FA state. Also, isn't the YJF page's reason for nomination invalid? Carlos requested it because he likes the subject of the page, not due to the actual article quality....)
(41 intermediate revisions by 8 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
  +
{{Shortcut|[[MGW:FA]]}}
{{Shortcut|[[MGW:FA]]}}The '''Featured Articles''' of the wiki are articles that represent the best the [[McLeodGaming Wiki:About|McLeodGaming Wiki]] has to offer. These articles are reviewed at featured article candidates for accuracy, completeness, and style its nomination process was created in order to highlight quality articles representative of the McLeodGaming Wiki. You should nominate articles based on their content, not because you like the subject. After an article is featured, this [[File:Featured.svg|30px|MG-esque golden star]] is added in the top right corner and it is showed in the main page.
+
The '''featured articles''' of the wiki are articles that represent the best the [[McLeodGaming Wiki:About|McLeodGaming Wiki]] has to offer. These articles are reviewed at featured article candidates for accuracy, completeness, and style its nomination process was created in order to highlight quality articles representative of the McLeodGaming Wiki. You should nominate articles based on their content, not because you like the subject. After an article is featured, this [[File:Featured.svg|30px|MG-esque golden star]] is added in the top right corner and it is shown in the main page.
   
 
== How to nominate an article ==
 
== How to nominate an article ==
Line 5: Line 6:
   
 
*Write the article you want to nominate in the box below
 
*Write the article you want to nominate in the box below
*Add the '''<nowiki>{{FAnomination}}</nowiki>''' tag at the top of the article.
+
*Add the '''<nowiki>{{FA nomination}}</nowiki>''' tag at the top of the article.
 
*Give your reasons in the section below and support or oppose the article, be sure to leave your signature with <nowiki>~~~~</nowiki>.
 
*Give your reasons in the section below and support or oppose the article, be sure to leave your signature with <nowiki>~~~~</nowiki>.
  +
*Neutral votes are also permissible, but in the end you will have to choose to whether support or oppose the article or else your vote will be invalidated.
   
 
<inputbox>
 
<inputbox>
 
type=create
 
type=create
default=McleodGaming Wiki:Featured Articles
+
default=McLeodGaming Wiki:Featured articles
 
width=50
 
width=50
 
buttonlabel=Nominate
 
buttonlabel=Nominate
Line 18: Line 20:
 
</inputbox>
 
</inputbox>
   
  +
== List of nominated articles ==
== Support/Oppose section ==
 
<!--ATTENTION: It has been decided that the page for Super Smash Flash 2 is not elegible to be featured due to the high activity the page has. This mostly because of the constant development updates from part of the developer team, which means the game is not complete but rather a demo. Once the full game gets released, the page, then, can be elegible to be featured.-->
+
<!--ATTENTION: It has been decided that the page for Super Smash Flash 2 is not elegible to be featured due to the high activity the page has. This is mostly because of the constant development updates from part of the developer team, which means the game is not complete but rather a demo. Once the full game gets released, the page, then, can be elegible to be featured.-->
 
Add the nominated article here by adding a heading 3 and specify your reasons why you want to make it featured article.
 
Add the nominated article here by adding the {{Font|130|'''<nowiki>=== Head line 3 ===</nowiki>'''}} with the article's name, and specified your reasons why you want to make it featured article.
 
   
=== [[School]] ===
+
=== ''[[Yeah Jam Fury]]'' ===
  +
#'''Support''': This is one of the best indie game I ever had. ''Yeah Jam Fury'' rules! [[User:Carloscreate100|Carloscreate100]] ([[User talk:Carloscreate100|talk]]) 23:00, April 20, 2018 (UTC)
#'''Support''': This is one of the most complete articles in the wiki and given the dedication of the same, this proves MG can be something else other than just ''SSF''. {{User:Byll/sig}}
 
#'''Support''': This is one of articles that not is of ''SSF'' or ''SSF2'', the majority of the people only see contend of ''SSF'' or ''SSF2'', the article deserves to be highlighted, for certain peoples see other stuffs. --'''[[User:Goku9|Goku9]] ([[User talk:Goku9|talk]])'''
+
#'''Neutral''': While not quite as big as the event page, this one represents a game that's come a long way on this wiki, and there's a bit of pride to be had in that. That said, the page itself isn't quite finished, and I think there's a lot to this game that just isn't documented right now, so I'd rather wait before casting my vote. --[[User:CrazyNaut|CrazyNaut]] ([[User talk:CrazyNaut|talk]]) 23:22, April 20, 2018 (UTC)
  +
#'''Oppose''': I was considering giving potential FA nominations to this page (and also its follow-up) some time in the future once it was improved, but at its current state it's not worthy even the nomination. Like CrazyNaut commented, the page isn't quite finished and the presence of an incomplete tag is the proof for that. --[[File:Ak-Un Symbol.PNG|30px|link=Special:Contributions/Byll|Haz clic aquí para ver mis contribuciones en la wiki.]] <big>[[User:Byll|<span style="font-family:Copperplate Bold;color:#B40404">'''BYLL'''</span>]] </big><span style="font-family:Copperplate Bold">'''EL'''</span> <big>[[User talk:Byll|<span style="font-family:Copperplate Bold;color:#610B0B">'''WYLL'''</span>]]</big> [[File:Ak-Un Symbol.PNG|30px|link=Special:Editcount/Byll|Haz clic aquí para ver cuantas ediciones he hecho.]] 03:22, April 26, 2018 (UTC)
  +
#'''Oppose''': Not yet, imo. It still needs some images before becoming a-okay. {{User:Goku9/sig}}
   
=== [[A Super Mario World Episode 2]] ===
+
=== [[Super Smash Flash 2 Demo|''Super Smash Flash 2'' Demo]] ===
#'''Support''': Definitely the best page I could wrote about this short-lived flash series of MG. With all the full-fledged content the episode offered, I was able to make a quite decent article detailing many aspect of the article. {{User:Byll/sig}}
+
#'''Support''': It is a very descriptive page, with a template giving many external links (a rare thing in this wiki) and documenting everything that could possibly be documented. I see myself coming back to that page regularly in order to check the release date of a demo in specific. {{User:Goku9/sig}}
  +
#'''Support''': This is one of our most popular pages and indeed has reached its improvement peak. So, per whay Gregory Naruto said, here's my support vote. --[[File:Ak-Un.PNG|30px|link=Special:Contributions/Byll|Haz clic aquí para ver mis contribuciones en la wiki.]] <big>[[User:Byll|<span style="font-family:Copperplate Bold;color:#B40404">'''BYLL'''</span>]] </big><span style="font-family:Copperplate Bold">'''EL'''</span> <big>[[User talk:Byll|<span style="font-family:Copperplate Bold;color:#610B0B">'''WYLL'''</span>]]</big> [[File:Ak-Un.PNG|30px|link=Special:Editcount/Byll|Haz clic aquí para ver cuantas ediciones he hecho.]] 22:20, July 20, 2019 (UTC)
   
  +
=== Comments/Remotion of opposing votes ===
== Featured content ==
 
  +
''None at the moment''
*<span style="font-size:120%">'''[[Mario]]'''</span> (at 15:27, 9 June 2009)
 
*<span style="font-size:120%">'''[[McLeodGaming]]'''</span> (at 15:43, 11 September 2009)
 
*<span style="font-size:120%">'''[[Mega Man]]'''</span> (at 15:23, 1 January 2010)
 
*<s><span style="font-size:120%">'''[[Smash Flash DOJO!!!]]'''</span> (at 23:56, 1 February 2010)</s> <small>(Unfeatured at 20:55 6 August 2013‎)</small>
 
*<span style="font-size:120%">'''[[Final Smash]]'''</span> (at 14:02, 30 June 2010)
 
*<span style="font-size:120%">'''''[[Super Smash Flash]]'''''</span> (at 19:02, 21 August 2010)
 
*<span style="font-size:120%">'''[[Lloyd Irving]]'''</span> (at 01:05, 20 December 2010)
 
*<s><span style="font-size:120%">'''[[Super Smash Flash 2 Expansion Forums|''Super Smash Flash 2'' Expansion Forums]]'''</span> (at 19:13, 20 August 2011)</s> <small>(Unfeatured at 19:32, 2 May 2015)</small>
 
*<span style="font-size:120%">'''[[Sonic the Hedgehog]]'''</span> (at 19:29, 2 May 2015)
 
   
  +
== List of candidates for unfeatural ==
[[Category:Featured articles|*]]
 
  +
=== Tier list ===
  +
#'''Support''': The page has had a cleanup tag on it for literal years; the controversies section looks informal and definitely does not represent the McLeodGaming Wiki (that's what featured articles are supposed to do). Nowadays we have multiple higher-quality pages, really. The SSF2 Tier list section also seems fairly incomplete, as it only describes the F tier. [[User:Gregory Naruto|<u><span style= "font-size:14px; font-family: Roboto;">'''Gregory'''</span></u>]][[File:SSF2_Zero_Suit_Samus_head.png|link=Message_Wall:Gregory Naruto]][[File:SSF2_Luffy_head.png|link=Message_Wall:Gregory Naruto]][[User:Gregory Naruto|<u><span style= "font-size:14px; font-family: Roboto;">'''Naruto'''</span></u>]] 20:13, August 6, 2020 (UTC)
  +
  +
== List of featured articles ==
 
*{{Font|120|'''[[Mario]]'''}} (at 15:27, 9 June 2009)
 
*{{Font|120|'''[[McLeodGaming]]'''}} (at 15:43, 11 September 2009)
 
*{{Font|120|'''[[Mega Man]]'''}} (at 15:23, 1 January 2010)
 
*<s>{{Font|120|'''[[Smash Flash DOJO!!!]]'''}} (at 23:56, 1 February 2010)</s> <small>(Unfeatured at 20:55 6 August 2013‎)</small>
  +
*<s>{{Font|120|'''[[Final Smash]]'''}} (at 14:02, 30 June 2010)</s> <small>(Unfeatured at 01:31, 5 January 2017)</small>
 
*{{Font|120|'''''[[Super Smash Flash]]'''''}} (at 19:02, 21 August 2010)
 
*{{Font|120|'''[[Lloyd Irving]]'''}} (at 01:05, 20 December 2010)
 
*<s>{{Font|120|'''[[Super Smash Flash 2 Expansion Forums|''Super Smash Flash 2'' Expansion Forums]]'''}} (at 19:13, 20 August 2011)</s> <small>(Unfeatured at 19:32, 2 May 2015)</small>
 
*{{Font|120|'''[[Sonic the Hedgehog]]'''}} (at 19:29, 2 May 2015)
  +
*{{Font|120|'''''[[School]]'''''}} (at 20:15, 1 August 2015)
  +
*{{Font|120|'''''[[A Super Mario World Episode 2]]'''''}} (at 02:05, 5 January 2017)
  +
*{{Font|120|'''[[Events]]'''}} (at 15:10, 31 August 2017)
  +
*{{Font|120|'''[[Nintendo 3DS]]'''}} (at 15:10, 31 August 2017)
  +
*{{Font|120|'''[[Final Destination (Super Smash Flash 2)|Final Destination (''Super Smash Flash 2'')]]'''}} (at 02:45, 16 September 2017)
  +
*{{Font|120|'''[[Gregory McLeod]]'''}} (at 03:00, 16 September 2017)
  +
*{{Font|120|'''[[Tier list]]'''}} (at 1:46, 30 July 2018)
  +
*{{Font|120|'''[[Food]]'''}} (at 17:22, 20 July, 2019)
  +
 
[[Category:Featured articles| {{PAGENAME}}]]

Revision as of 20:13, 6 August 2020

Shortcut:
MGW:FA

The featured articles of the wiki are articles that represent the best the McLeodGaming Wiki has to offer. These articles are reviewed at featured article candidates for accuracy, completeness, and style its nomination process was created in order to highlight quality articles representative of the McLeodGaming Wiki. You should nominate articles based on their content, not because you like the subject. After an article is featured, this MG-esque golden star is added in the top right corner and it is shown in the main page.

How to nominate an article

To nominate an article be featured, please do the following:

  • Write the article you want to nominate in the box below
  • Add the {{FA nomination}} tag at the top of the article.
  • Give your reasons in the section below and support or oppose the article, be sure to leave your signature with ~~~~.
  • Neutral votes are also permissible, but in the end you will have to choose to whether support or oppose the article or else your vote will be invalidated.

List of nominated articles

Add the nominated article here by adding a heading 3 and specify your reasons why you want to make it featured article.

Yeah Jam Fury

  1. Support: This is one of the best indie game I ever had. Yeah Jam Fury rules! Carloscreate100 (talk) 23:00, April 20, 2018 (UTC)
  2. Neutral: While not quite as big as the event page, this one represents a game that's come a long way on this wiki, and there's a bit of pride to be had in that. That said, the page itself isn't quite finished, and I think there's a lot to this game that just isn't documented right now, so I'd rather wait before casting my vote. --CrazyNaut (talk) 23:22, April 20, 2018 (UTC)
  3. Oppose: I was considering giving potential FA nominations to this page (and also its follow-up) some time in the future once it was improved, but at its current state it's not worthy even the nomination. Like CrazyNaut commented, the page isn't quite finished and the presence of an incomplete tag is the proof for that. --Haz clic aquí para ver mis contribuciones en la wiki. BYLL EL WYLL Haz clic aquí para ver cuantas ediciones he hecho. 03:22, April 26, 2018 (UTC)
  4. Oppose: Not yet, imo. It still needs some images before becoming a-okay. GregorySSF2 Zero Suit Samus stock iconSSF2 Luffy stock iconNaruto

Super Smash Flash 2 Demo

  1. Support: It is a very descriptive page, with a template giving many external links (a rare thing in this wiki) and documenting everything that could possibly be documented. I see myself coming back to that page regularly in order to check the release date of a demo in specific. GregorySSF2 Zero Suit Samus stock iconSSF2 Luffy stock iconNaruto
  2. Support: This is one of our most popular pages and indeed has reached its improvement peak. So, per whay Gregory Naruto said, here's my support vote. --Haz clic aquí para ver mis contribuciones en la wiki. BYLL EL WYLL Haz clic aquí para ver cuantas ediciones he hecho. 22:20, July 20, 2019 (UTC)

Comments/Remotion of opposing votes

None at the moment

List of candidates for unfeatural

Tier list

  1. Support: The page has had a cleanup tag on it for literal years; the controversies section looks informal and definitely does not represent the McLeodGaming Wiki (that's what featured articles are supposed to do). Nowadays we have multiple higher-quality pages, really. The SSF2 Tier list section also seems fairly incomplete, as it only describes the F tier. GregoryFile:SSF2 Zero Suit Samus head.pngFile:SSF2 Luffy head.pngNaruto 20:13, August 6, 2020 (UTC)

List of featured articles